Appeals court allows takings claims over Seattle renter rules tied to 254-unit affordable complex in receivership
A Washington Court of Appeals ruling allows GRE Downtowner LLC to proceed with claims that Seattle’s rental regulations amounted to an unconstitutional taking, a dispute tied to the 254-unit Addison on Fourth affordable housing development that later went into receivership, Fox News Digital reported.
Fox News Digital reported that GRE says the rules helped destroy a $39 million investment in the project. GRE alleges rent collections fell from 93.9% in 2018 to 44.1% in 2023 and that the property suffered nearly $5.8 million in cumulative operating losses after a series of city ordinances, contributing to a mortgage default and a federal receiver taking control in January 2026.
The property operated under the federal Low-Income Housing Tax Credit program, Fox News Digital reported, and GRE is pursuing compensation under an inverse-condemnation theory that seeks payment when government actions effectively take or damage private property without just compensation.
Sean Flynn, executive director of the Rental Housing Association of Washington, told Fox News Digital he is working with GRE and said successive landlord-targeted ordinances created a “toxic cocktail of legislation” that destroyed the investment.
Fox News Digital quoted Ilya Somin, a George Mason University law professor, saying the ruling is “more significant than just a routine legal decision” because courts in other states could consider it in similar constitutional challenges. Somin compared Seattle’s roommate ordinance to the Supreme Court’s Cedar Point Nursery v. Hassid decision in arguing the provision raises a per se taking question.
The Seattle City Attorney’s Office told Fox News Digital that officials are reviewing the appellate ruling and weighing next steps. “We haven’t made a decision on an appeal yet,” Chief of Staff Dan Nolte said in an email to Fox News Digital.
Fox News Digital noted the complaint traces the property’s positive cash flow from 2015 through 2018 and describes a sequence of Seattle ordinances limiting criminal-background checks, expanding occupants’ rights, restricting certain evictions and requiring relocation assistance after qualifying rent increases.
Fox News Digital also reported that similar landlord restrictions exist in other large U.S. cities, including San Francisco, New York City, Portland and Philadelphia, and noted property-owner groups warn those policies can deter investment in rental housing.
Source: Latest & Breaking News on Fox News
